Blog PostsNew Careers for Rom-Com Leading Ladies

After writing my “Battle of the Sexes” post last night, I started thinking about the leading female characters in romantic comedies and the careers they follow.

Mindy Kaling has pointed out in a great New Yorker article that romantic comedies are often populated by women who work in art galleries. She writes,

“How many freakin’ art galleries are out there? Are people buying visual art on a daily basis? This posh/smart/classy profession is a favorite in movies. It’s in the same realm as kindergarten teacher or children’s-book illustrator in terms of accessibility: guys don’t really get it, but it is likable and nonthreatening.”

Kaling is absolutely right (and she writes more of these witty observations in her book Is Everyone Hanging Out Without Me?, so read it!) I’d also like to add to the list of acceptable professions for romantic comedy leading women: children’s bookstore owner (Meg Ryan in You’ve Got Mail), woman who works in the publishing industry, usually for a woman’s magazine (Kate Hudson in How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days, Jennifer Garner in 13 Going on 30, Drew Barrymore in Going the Distance), baker who specializes in cupcakes (Ashley Williams in How I Met Your Mother – yes, it’s a TV show, but it counts). These jobs are professional but acceptably feminine and nonthreatening for the male lead.

(For the record, I’m not trying to imply that female-dominated careers are inherently less worthy than male-dominated careers, or that a woman having a baker or publishing career is anti-feminist. I’m only pointing out that there isn’t a lot of variety of careers for women in romantic comedies.)

Of course, sometimes female characters have high-powered jobs or careers in male-dominated fields. Sometimes they even have executive positions. Usually, though, the high-powered businesswomen is the type who barks into a phone and has to learn that there are More Important Things Than Work – like true love! (Insert examples from oh so many movies.) Or, like Katherine Heigl in 27 Dresses, these characters are the assistants of high-powered executives in nondescript business careers, and as a fun bonus, they’re in love with their bosses (at least temporarily).

Well, I think it’s about time for romantic comedy leading women to explore more diverse career options. Here is a list of careers I would like to see for our romantic leading women.

High school trigonometry teacher
Romantic comedies love their kindergarten and elementary school teachers. Why not expand the field to include secondary teachers – better yet, female teachers of mathematics? As a former eighth grade English teacher, I have it on good authority that female math teachers do exist, and they fall in love just as easily as elementary school teachers. Her male lead can woo her with a rendition of 2ge+her’s “U + Me = Us (Calculus)” and write her proofs instead of love letters. The movie would be even better if we could get in a Dangerous Minds reference except with math instead of poetry.

Accountant
Better yet, an accountant that actually likes her job. When a guy tries to save her from her humdrum life and pursue a more artistic, “fulfilling” career, she says, “No thanks, I enjoy doing people’s taxes and getting a good salary. I’m cool with saving my violin playing/doll making/cupcake baking as a weekend hobby.” On the other hand, that would make for a really short movie, wouldn’t it? I might have to reconsider this as a viable rom-com leading woman career option.

Genetic scientist
A genetic scientist who works so hard at her job that she never has time to pursue a love life, so she decides to create a perfect man by using cloning techniques! Think a role-reversal Pygmalion crossed with Frankenstein, except with more adorable montages and cute music. Actually, this would work better as a sci-fi horror movie.

Urologist
No, see, it’s funny because she’s a woman and she’s a penis doctor! Get it? Then she develops a romance with a male ob-gyn. The movie will be called His and Hers.

Guitarist in a death metal band
I envision this romantic comedy leading lady looking, sounding, and dressing exactly like Zooey Deschanel, but then scares everyone with her frightening death metal guitar skills. She falls in love with a rapper.

Prosecuting attorney
Let’s have a remake of Adam’s Rib, but with the male attorney defending the woman who shot her husband, as his wife works as the prosecutor. I’m actually serious about this suggestion. The typical “battle of the sexes” story will be turned on its head with the man defending a woman and a woman prosecuting on behalf of a man (and the state).

Plumber
I want a Community film spinoff where a female plumber falls in love with a man enrolled in Greendale’s sinister air conditioner repair school. They’re initially prejudiced against each other because of the war between the two majors, but they fall in love despite that and change the system from within! Troy Barnes and Britta Perry obviously have large parts in this film, and Jerry Minor can return as the father of the female plumber.

Feminist blogger/activist
A feminist blogger/activist who fights against sexism but secretly believes that all men suck meets a guy who DOESN’T suck, and then she completely reevaluates everything she ever thought about sexism and decides to be nicer to men. But at the end of the movie, the man kisses this feminist woman and finds out that she’s completely made of straw. The End.

How about the rest of you? What careers would you like to see for romantic comedy leading women? Offer suggestions in the comments.

This entry was posted in Blog Posts and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to New Careers for Rom-Com Leading Ladies

  1. Laura says:

    So many things I could respond to in here 😀 I think that last guy should try to get in contact with Batman sometime soon because it sounds like he was just gassed by Jonathan Crane.

    On the subject of Math teachers/accountants/people who make a profession out of dealing with those scary squiggles that weren’t given to us by the Phoenicians, I’ve heard great things about the romance novel “Bet Me” by Jennifer Crusie, the main female lead of which I believe is a statistician.

  2. Courtney says:

    Since you mentioned HIMYM, don’t forget that Alyson Hannigan’s character is a kindergarten teacher. Also, Maggie Gyllenhall’s character in Stranger than Fiction dropped out of Harvard Law to become a baker.

    • Lady T says:

      I had forgotten that Maggie Gyllenhall’s character used to be in Harvard Law. I really like that movie, but yeah, that particular trope is pretty over-used.

  3. Gareth says:

    Aphrodite in a rom com. Does her whole goddess of love thing only to meet a man and learn that her view of love is completely invalid and change her whole outlook on life to match his by the end of the movie. I was never good at titles so I’ll just stick with a working title of “Love Goddess”

  4. >.Better yet, an accountant that actually likes her job. When a guy tries to save her from her humdrum life and pursue a more artistic, “fulfilling” career, she says, “No thanks, I enjoy doing people’s taxes and getting a good salary. I’m cool with saving my violin playing/doll making/cupcake baking as a weekend hobby.” On the other hand, that would make for a really short movie, wouldn’t it? I might have to reconsider this as a viable rom-com leading woman career option.<<

    Let me introduce you to Kendra McQueen, from Something New. She is a high powered Accountant/executive in a major firm, and while yes the general idea is she has to "let go let flow" when it comes to love it's never zero summed against her being super competent at and satisfied with her job. Her issues are portrayed as being about an inability to trust in general and the desire to fit cultural, familial, and social expectations rather than examine what in a relationship actually makes her happy.

    Oh also Gwen from Miami Rhapsody is a Advertising Account exec who struggles with similar issues of trust/intimacy that have nothing to do with her being good at and liking her job and again have more to do with her family and the culture. The ending of that movie is kind of amazing in anti-rom com kind of ending, it's very similar to the kind of truthy so real it hurts kind of thing from Kicking/Screaming and Freaks/Geeks. That's my kind of romcom!

  5. Elizabethh says:

    Re: Genetic Scientist, Sarah Polley played a geneticist in a film called “Splice” a few years ago that was definitely sci-fi horror rather than rom-com. Her character, Elsa, started off rather refreshingly and had lots of ambition, smarts, and drive but she was slowly revealed to be ambitious because she is Evil and Crazy™ and her co-scientist and love interest Clive is somehow long-suffering and unable to make choices for himself because she is domineering and terrible, etc. What started out as a New and Different career for a woman on film slowly became just another way to create a sexist portrayal of a woman on screen.

    • Lady T says:

      Aw man, that’s so disappointing, especially when the character is played by Sarah Polley. I’m betting her performance was still good but that premise is so problematic.

  6. That last one better be “present company excepted,” because you, my dear, are no straw woman.

    • Lady T says:

      Thank you! In all seriousness, though, I would really love to see a parody of the straw feminist trope. Maybe I’ll write it someday…

Leave a Reply